Photo: Kenneth Parkhurst JrBig Tony's Pizzeria
About Big Tony's Pizzeria in Cookeville, TN
Big Tony's Pizzeria is at 866 E 10th St. Tony Nigro and Elizabeth Nigro opened it in 2017. The Cookeville Scoop pizza guide describes the pizza as New York-style thin crust.
Cookeville Lifestyle Magazine's April 10, 2024, profile names daughter Stormy alongside Tony and Liz. Tony told the magazine they make dough every day and make their own sauce and alfredo, and that some recipes are at least a hundred years old. The article says the restaurant delivers within 10 miles. It also describes a Pay It Forward board, which Stormy suggested, where customers can buy meals for other people.
The Facebook page linked from the listing did not return a menu on October 12, 2026, so this page does not add a current item list or a weekly hours table. Call (931) 400-0044 before you go.
What to Order
The Cookeville Scoop pizza guide describes the pizza as New York-style thin crust. Tony Nigro told Cookeville Lifestyle Magazine the dough, sauce, and alfredo are made in the restaurant. The magazine said delivery runs within 10 miles.
“Good pizza option on the north side of town.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Big Tony's Pizzeria do?
Big Tony's serves New York-style thin-crust pizza. Tony Nigro told Cookeville Lifestyle Magazine in 2024 that the restaurant makes dough every day and makes its own sauce and alfredo. Delivery is within 10 miles.
Where is Big Tony's Pizzeria?
Big Tony's Pizzeria is at 866 E 10th St, Cookeville, TN 38501.
What are Big Tony's Pizzeria's hours?
A current weekly hours table was not on a menu page on October 12, 2026. Call (931) 400-0044 before you go.
Stay in the loop on Cookeville
The Cookeville Scoop newsletter covers local news, events, and community updates - delivered free to your inbox.