Cookeville has New York-style thin crust, a converted school bus with customer-set pricing, a family restaurant open since 1992, and a pub pizza.
What Makes Great Pizza in Cookeville
The pizza places on this list treat the crust as its own part of the pie, with structure and flavor before sauce and cheese. They use a generous amount of cheese, toppings, and sauce with a distinct taste. The same places produce a similar pie on a Tuesday night and on a busy Saturday.
1. Big Tony's Pizzeria
866 E 10th St | (931) 400-0044 | bigtonyspizza.us
Big Tony's Pizzeria is at 866 E 10th St. Big Tony's has 4.7 stars across 353 reviews. The style is New York-influenced thin crust: a foldable slice, a crisp bottom, and chew. The menu has garlic knots, calzones, and specialty pies. The calzones are fully filled. Pepperoni is also on the menu. The phone line moves fast, and delivery runs on time.
2. Cookeville Pizza & Pub
707 Mahler Ave | (931) 854-0759 | ckvlpizza.com
Cookeville Pizza & Pub is at 707 Mahler Ave. The restaurant is a bar with pizza. Craft beer is on tap. Regulars describe the crust as crunchy chewy perfection. The crust snaps, then gives. The menu is short.
3. Mamma Rosa's Italian Restaurant
200 S Lowe Ave | (931) 372-8694 | mammarosasitalian.com
Mamma Rosa's is at 200 S Lowe Ave. Mamma Rosa's has been open since 1992 and is family-owned. The menu has pizza, pasta, and bread. The pizza is Italian-American style, thick enough to be filling, with simmered sauce and melted cheese. Mamma Rosa's has 4.0 stars across 263 reviews. Mamma Rosa's seats parents and children. The first-visit order named here is lasagna and a pizza to share.
4. Gene's Place Pizzeria
4 W Spring St | (931) 651-1338 | genesplacepizzeria.com
Gene's Place is at 4 W Spring St, on the downtown square. Gene's is a pizzeria and pub. Parking around the square can mean a short walk. The pies are pub pizzas with moderate portions. The bar is busy on weekend nights. Gene's is also open for lunch.
5. The Pizza Machine
Rolling food truck | follow on social for locations
The Pizza Machine is a converted school bus. The customer sets the price. The Pizza Machine is at events, breweries, and markets. The schedule changes. Follow The Pizza Machine on social media for locations.
6. Domino's and Papa John's
Domino's and Papa John's both have locations in Cookeville. Both deliver. A stated delivery window in this section is 30 minutes.
7. Riverhouse Pizza
Check current hours and location
Riverhouse Pizza is a local pizza option. Check current hours and location.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Cookeville, TN? Big Tony's Pizzeria at 866 E 10th St has 4.7 stars across more than 350 reviews. The pizza is New York-style thin crust, and the menu includes specialty pies.
Is there good pizza in Cookeville? Big Tony's, Cookeville Pizza & Pub, and Mamma Rosa's are independent pizza options in Cookeville. The Pizza Machine is a food truck.
Where do locals eat pizza in Cookeville? Locals use Big Tony's for delivery or carryout, Cookeville Pizza & Pub for pizza with beer, and Mamma Rosa's for a sit-down Italian meal. Gene's Place on the square has a downtown crowd.
Does Cookeville have New York-style pizza? Big Tony's Pizzeria makes New York-style thin crust pizza. The slice folds, the bottom is crisp, and the crust has chew.
What pizza places deliver in Cookeville? Big Tony's delivers. The national chains deliver. Call ahead to confirm delivery radius and hours. Carryout is also available at the independent shops on this list.
Big Tony's is the first pizza place on this list. The Pizza Machine posts its schedule when the bus is out.